| (44.01) | ||||
| 09/05/09 | hosting | Ohio Wesleyan | (40.88) | 19-7 |
| 09/12/09 | hosting | Grove City | (46.03) | 45-40 |
| 09/19/09 | at | Hobart | (45.83) | 16-24 |
| 09/26/09 | at | Hiram | (34.87) | 42-3 |
| 10/03/09 | at | Kenyon | (41.04) | 17-14 |
| 10/10/09 | hosting | Allegheny | (46.23) | 35-38 |
| 10/24/09 | at | Wittenberg | (51.66) | 7-28 |
| 10/31/09 | hosting | Washington U. | (43.94) | 21-13 |
| 11/07/09 | hosting | Case Western Reserve | (48.67) | 17-34 |
| 11/14/09 | at | Chicago | (44.22) | 7-24 |