| (40.42) | ||||
| 09/05/09 | hosting | Shenandoah | (43.09) | 3-21 |
| 09/12/09 | at | Franklin & Marshall | (49.28) | 21-42 |
| 09/19/09 | at | McDaniel | (45.08) | 17-21 |
| 09/26/09 | hosting | Randolph-Macon | (46.81) | 21-31 |
| 10/10/09 | at | Washington and Lee | (44.81) | 14-28 |
| 10/17/09 | at | Gallaudet | (37.91) | 38-13 |
| 10/24/09 | hosting | Hampden-Sydney | (51.08) | 7-21 |
| 10/31/09 | hosting | Emory & Henry | (47.53) | 10-13 |
| 11/07/09 | hosting | Guilford | (43.56) | 21-42 |
| 11/14/09 | at | Bridgewater VA | (47.11) | 13-30 |